+91 90708 00090 +91 62396 34781 [email protected]
27,153 students voted GM the best mock test series for CA, CS & CMA

New Forum Topic

Student Discussion Forum

Connect with peers, ask exam queries, and share preparation tips.

Anonymous
Posted on 8th January,2021 11:45 AM

section for auditor for his willfull contravenes

If an auditor willfully  Contravenes the provisions of Section 139 to 148 then is he liable for penalty under section 147 or Penalty under section 447 or both? Explain\r\n
Audit Internal Audit 1 total replies

Replies & Answers (1)

BMC Associates 7th August,2026 10:47 PM

The key distinction is between a specific penalty under Section 147 and the consequences of fraud under Section 447. Under the Companies Act, 2013, if an auditor contravenes the provisions relating to audit and auditors under Sections 139 to 148, the specific penalty provision is Section 147. Section 147(2) provides punishment for certain contraventions by the company and, in specified circumstances, the auditor. However, Section 147 and Section 447 are not necessarily mutually exclusive. If the auditor's conduct amounts to fraud as defined under Section 447, and the requirements for applying Section 447 are satisfied, the auditor may also face punishment under Section 447. Section 447 deals specifically with fraudulent acts and is not limited to technical or procedural non-compliance. Therefore, simply willfully contravening Sections 139–148 does not automatically mean Section 447 applies. The facts must establish fraud for Section 447 to be invoked. For professional guidance on Companies Act compliance, audit requirements, and auditor liabilities, businesses can consult experienced chartered accountant firms in gurgaon, a qualified chartered accountant gurgaon, a reliable ca firm in gurgaon, or a professional ca in gurgaon.

Post your answer or reply

You need to sign in to post a reply on the student forum.

Sign in to Reply

Write & Upload Tests on GM Mobile App

Scan answer sheets, receive verified evaluations, and chat with faculty directly on Android & iOS.